Assess what students will need

Knowledge remains the foundation of learning. Students need to know things to think with them.

But knowledge is no longer the finish line.

AI can answer questions, summarize texts, write essays, generate presentations and solve increasingly complex problems. It also makes much of the evidence schools traditionally use to assess learning easier to produce without actually doing the learning.

That creates two challenges at once.

We need better ways to know that students have actually learned. And we need to raise the bar for what learning prepares them to do.

Knowing something matters. But increasingly, students will also need to explain it, apply it in unfamiliar situations, connect it to other ideas, create with it, collaborate around it and communicate it to other people.

These aren’t replacements for knowledge. They’re what knowledge makes possible.

The challenge is that many of these capabilities don’t fit neatly into the artifacts schools have traditionally collected.

You can assess an essay after it has been written. It’s harder to see how a student developed an idea. You can grade the answer to a problem. It’s harder to see whether a student can explain the reasoning, respond to a challenge or transfer the concept to a new situation.

Much of the evidence exists while students are doing the work.

That should change what we capture.

A discussion can become evidence. A student explaining an idea can become evidence. So can a debate, presentation, collaborative problem, performance, creation or reflection. Instead of relying primarily on the final artifact, we can preserve more of the learning that produced it.

This doesn’t mean making assessment easier or less rigorous.

It means making it harder to fake.

And it creates room for richer learning experiences because teachers no longer have to reduce everything that matters to something easily collected and scored.

Students learn what matters partly from what schools ask them to demonstrate.

If explanation, creation, application, transfer, collaboration and communication will matter in their future, they should matter in school now.

Assess what students will need—and create learning worthy of the assessment.